­
  • Home
  • Match Centre
  • British & Irish Lions
  • Videos
  • Supabets
  • Cars
    • Motoring News
    • Used Cars For Sale
    • New Cars For Sale
    • Demo Cars For Sale
  • Daddy’s Deals

SA Rugbymag

South African rugby news, fixtures, results, video, interviews, and more. Covering the Springboks, Bulls, Stormers/Western Province, Sharks, Cheetahs, Kings and Lions, as well as schools and club rugby.

Primary Menu Search
  • Home
  • Match Centre
  • British & Irish Lions
  • Videos
  • Supabets
  • Cars
    • Motoring News
    • Used Cars For Sale
    • New Cars For Sale
    • Demo Cars For Sale
  • Daddy’s Deals

You are here: Home ∼ Final must have neutral officials

Final must have neutral officials

Published on July 30, 2017 | Leave a response

Sanzaar must appoint neutral officials for the Super Rugby final between the Lions and Crusaders at Ellis Park, writes SIMON BORCHARDT.

On Saturday, the Lions overturned a 22-3 deficit in their semi-final against the Hurricanes to claim a famous 44-29 victory.

The Canes started to tire at the end of the first half, and missed a couple of try-scoring opportunities that would probably have finished off the Lions. They also allowed their opponents to score a morale-boosting try just before the break. 

The effect of a long fight across the Indian Ocean and the altitude took its toll on the defending champions in the second half, while the Lions successfully changed tactics, playing a more direct, pragmatic game that resulted in 34 points.

Yet instead of the above being discussed in depth, it was the performance of the South African officials that attracted the most attention in some media outlets, especially in New Zealand.

The most talked-about incident of the match was referee Jaco Peyper's decision to yellow card Beauden Barrett in the 58th minute when the Canes were leading 29-22. Ruan Combrinck had broken away into the Canes 22 before being tackled by Barrett 6m out from the tryline.

While trying to move away from the ruck, Barrett kicked the ball away – intentionally or unintentionally, depending on who you ask – costing the Lions a great try-scoring opportunity.

Peyper insisted that Barrett was on the wrong side and because he'd had an influence on the game, had to be penalised. However, the South African referee also believe it warranted a yellow card, much to Canes captain Dane Coles' disgust, and the Lions would score 17 points while the flyhalf was off.

The Canes were also unhappy when Peyer chose not to refer Malcolm Marx's 53rd-minute try from a lineout driving maul to the TMO after he had been told by South African assistant referee Rasta Rasivhenge that the ball had definitely been grounded. Peyper asked Rasivhenge if he should check with the TMO, and he said no. Rasivhenge's supporters will say he did well to back himself and make the call, while his detractors will say he should have just let the TMO check it in such a big game.

Peyper and Rasivhenge got both of the above decisions correct in my view, but because they are South African, and the decisions went the way of the South African side against a New Zealand side, there was perceived bias.

The only way to prevent accusations of bias is to appoint neutral officials. 

Sanzaar scrapped its policy of having neutral officials in Super Rugby to save on travel and accommodation costs, but surely a final played in front of 60,000 fans is worth the expense?

Angus Gardner, Australia's best referee, must take charge of Saturday's decider at Ellis Park and there should be Australian, Argentinian or Japanese assistant referees and TMO (please, Sanzaar, just try to find someone other than George Ayoub, who is the worst TMO in world rugby).

That will ensure that if the Crusaders do lose, it will be because the Lions were the better team and not because of bias – conscious or subconscious – from local officials.

And if you are a South African who doesn't think there should be neutral officials for this final, just ask yourself how you would feel if it was being played in Christchurch instead, with four New Zealand officials.

OPINION: Lions have final lesson to learn

Photo: Kai Schwoerer/Getty Images

Posted in Uncategorized

Post by Simon Borchardt

Simon Borchardt

MPU #1 - (DESKTOP SIZE 300x250 / MOBILE SIZE 320x50, 300x250, 320x100)
← Previous Next →

Ratings: Du Toit one of the few standouts for Boks

The Boks faded in the second half to slump to a 22-17...

Five key areas the Boks need to dominate for first victory

SA Rugby magazine highlights five crucial areas the Boks will need to...

Duhan should be celebrated for his Lions success

Duhan van der Merwe’s achievements should be truly appreciated by South Africans,...

JdV: Boks-Lions have everything to play for

Performing in empty stadiums will be a key factor in the series...

Dynamic Dayimani: Forward to back

While he has been signed as an ‘edge’ forward, Hacjivah Dayimani could...

Boks have muscle memory to rely on

Rassie Erasmus and Jacques Nienaber are experts at finding solutions to tricky...

Top six: Best and worst foreign imports

SARugbymag.co.za identifies six of the best and worst foreign players to play...

Column: When context is needed

As highlighted by the Argentina controversy, ‘cancel culture’ needs a spoonful of...

Dark cloud hangs over WP Rugby

The problems at Western Province Rugby are layered, and everyone involved needs...

From the mag: Foreign Favourites

As Vodacom Super Rugby turned 25 this year, JON CARDINELLI picks an...

Bulls rookies to watch

After a massive exodus of players the Vodacom Bulls will be eager...

Analysis: The new suffocate-and-strangle game

For the Boks to emerge as World Cup winners, they need to...

VIEW MORE
  • Team graphics: Springboks vs B&I Lions
  • Boks vs Lions (1st Test): Predict and WIN!
  • Lions team announcement: Duhan to front Boks
  • Teams: SA A vs Bulls
Boks

Why the Boks should be bullish

There is good reason for the Springboks to enter the British & Irish Lions series with confidence, writes MARK KEOHANE in the latest SA Rugby magazine.

  • Watch: Did Gatland’s words influence Jonker?


COVID-19 Corona Virus
South African Resource Portal

ABOUT

  • Contact us
  • Competitions
  • Videos
  • Player Features
  • Subscribe
  • Terms and conditions
  • Privacy Policy

TOURNAMENTS

    • Rugby Championship
    • Super Rugby
    • Currie Cup
    • Varsity Cup
    • Gold Cup
    • Schools
    • Six Nations
    • Champions Cup
    • World Cup

OPINION

  • Mallett on SuperSport
  • Cardinelli column
  • Lewis column
  • Xabanisa column
  • Borchardt column
  • Superbru

Primary Menu

  • Home
  • Match Centre
  • British & Irish Lions
  • Videos
  • Supabets
  • Cars
    • Motoring News
    • Used Cars For Sale
    • New Cars For Sale
    • Demo Cars For Sale
  • Daddy’s Deals
×